| Games | Athlete/Team | Placement | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1912 Summer Olympics | Jim Thorpe | 1 | Gold |
| Jim Donahue | 3 | Silver | |
| Austin Menaul | 5 | ||
| Avery Brundage | 6 | ||
| Jack Eller | 19 | ||
| Harry Frykberg | DNS | ||
| Platt Adams | DNS | ||
| Harry Babcock | DNS | ||
| Dick Byrd | DNS | ||
| Roy Mercer | DNS | ||
| George Philbrook | DNS | ||
| 1920 Summer Olympics | Everett Bradley | 2 | Silver |
| Bob LeGendre | 4 | ||
| Brutus Hamilton | 6 | ||
| Robert Dunne | 13 | ||
| 1924 Summer Olympics | Bob LeGendre | 3 | Bronze |
| Mort Kaer | 5 | ||
| Brutus Hamilton | 7 | ||
| Clifford Argue | 12 |
